Thanks so much, TykeMan! We did our Keswick trip today and wound up at the George Hotel for lunch - I had the most massive steak and ale pie that I've ever seen, and that was the HALF portion!
We're heading south tomorrow and will definitely check out The Feathers.
Vicky, I checked beerintheevening but the site does seem to skew more towards drink than food reviews - still, a good resource!