Guya --
Thanks for your reply, but I'm somewhat financially illiterate and don't really understand.
What does "on the arising basis" refer to?
Are you saying that the UK taxes take precedence over the US, even though the income is from US Social Security?
For 2010, I also cashed out my TIAA-Cref pension fund to buy the UK house, and took a big tax hit in the US. Do you know how that affects things?