Fantasy X Factor

I read on Digital Spy that Simon Cowell wants to get Robbie Williams to be a judge on X Factor.  I absolutely loathe the guy,  I don't think I'll be able to watch if he's on it, which got me to thinking who I would liike to see as judges - total fantasy of course but I came up with Morrissey, Siouxsie (both of whom I am sure would be hugely acerbic and subversive) and Duffy to balance things out a bit.  Amy Winehouse would be a hoot too.

Anyone else want to play?

Sorry, but I wouldn't watch if Morrissey were a judge! I can't stand him! 

But this is a fun game! Let's see ... I'd like to see Cher. She wouldn't hold back. Simon would be scared. I'd also like to see Bob Dylan, some Gallaghers (either or both), Debbie Harry, Tom Jones, Pete Doherty, Adam Ant, Cyndi Lauper, Lou Reed, Michael Stipe and maybe a cranky old b*stard like ... I was going to say Mel Torme, but I think he's dead.

Not that I watch it much anyway but what the heck I'll join in!

Lilly Allen & Taylor Swift both of them are also song writers. Hmm....need a man....Lionel Ritchie because I think he is such a nice guy (at least in the interviews I've seen him in).

I just thought of someone else who would be severely grumpy and probably end up coming to blows with Simon Cowell - Paul Weller!!

Lily Allen would be good actually, a hipper, brainier version of Cheryl Cole.

Lily Allen would be good actually, a hipper, brainier version of Cheryl Cole.

A two-by-four would be a hipper, brainier version of Cheryl Cole! 

But I really like Lily Allen and I think she'd be great!

I'm too tired to think of any good ones right now but THIS!!!

A two-by-four would be a hipper, brainier version of Cheryl Cole!