Thanks all, would appreciate some help re our FBAR quandary above. In the meantime, we'll look at TaxAct (workaround noted ), TaxSlayer and OLT and see which seems most straightforward. I'm hoping once we've got a platform that works for us, future years will be more straightforward.
All help appreciated!
Greg
As others have mentioned, on the FBAR, it doesn't care about your highest balance on one specific day, the cross-correlation exercise isn't necessary. There are two questions to answer:
1. Do I need to file an FBAR? Answer: If the total value of all non-US accounts exceeded $10k at any point in the year, yes.
2. What value do I report on the FBAR? Answer: FBAR is set up by account, and you report the highest balance in the year for each account.
Example: Account A had $9k on 01Jan, less than that every other day: report $9k
Account B had $5k on 15Apr, less than that on every other day: report $5k
Account C had $7k on 31Dec, less than that on every other day: report $7k
Note that this even applies if it's the same money. If you transferred the $5k from Account A to Account B, so that Account A was $9k on 01Jan, $4k after transferring $5k to Account B, you still report $9k for A and $5k for B. Yes, this means you're double/triple/quadruple/etc. counting the same money, but that's fine. FBAR isn't interested in you reporting the total amount you have in non-US accounts, but the highest amount you had in each account at any point in the year.
FBAR is a bit of a faff to set up the first year, but after that it's pretty straightforward. I keep an Excel file of all my non-US accounts, with the basic information they need every year (account #, address, etc.), and just fill in the highest value in GBP and use a simple Excel formula to convert to USD. Exchange rate is simple for FBAR too, no need to look it up for each date, just use the "Treasury's Financial Management Service" rate for all the values (
https://www.fincen.gov/reporting-maximum-account-value). Takes maybe 15 minutes each January, nothing to stress about - far easier to just file it and include any account you think might be applicable, people spend too much time worrying about "do I need to report this funky kind of account?" and "my total balance might have been $9,999.99 or $10,000 depending how you round it, should I file an FBAR?" If in doubt, just report it and sleep well.
Lastly, remember FBAR has NOTHING to do with your taxes. Doesn't go to the same US government agency, nothing on the FBAR causes you to pay or not pay any taxes. It is purely reporting (and in some cases, duplicate reporting with your tax return - that's life outside the US...).