In a former marriage, I felt exactly the same way as you sweetpeach. So I decided to hyphenate my maiden and married names.
Within the first year, I deeply regretted it. LOADS of reasons, but the ones I recall:
- it was too long to write out all the time (and not counting the hyphen, it was ONLY 8 letters!)
- when my son was born, people were confused as to what to call him (was his last name hyphenated too? people wanted to do the right thing, but it only confounded)
- my doctor files were always misplaced...and I think it got so ridiculous that one vital file may have been thrown out (you see, they had filing people in and out of the office all the time, different people. Was it under my maiden? Was it under my married? No one could ever find my files after they'd been put away...doctor, dentist...no one)
- being introduced was awkward...the name's just too difficult to roll off and still sound cool, but again, everyone wanted to do the right thing, and after a few miserable tries, they all ended up just not introducing me to people
- no one could remember which name came first
- it was odd enough for people to look at me like I'd grown a second nose (why couldn't I 'just be conventional?' was in their thoughts)
- when I divorced, having to tack THAT name onto my precious maiden name each and every signature...it just really irked me. A constant reminder that in a bizarre way I am still linked to this man.
I hated hated hated that hyphenated name. So when I remarried, I knew I wanted to take on my husband's name. Afterall, they could never change the person I am inside. A name is something convenient people call you. It's not a label of who you are.
But...this is my own experience. I can't say the same for anyone else out there.