VIDEO CONNECTIONS
There have been several queries about video connections for TV recently, so I thought I'd add some notes about the various methods of connecting equipment together. This will involve something of a lesson in the basic principles of color television, but if you can follow these you will have a much better understanding of how the different types of interconnection work. I'll try to keep the technical talk to the minimum necessary!
I'm sure that everybody is aware of the fact that a basic black-&-white TV picture is made up by scanning from left to right and top to bottom of the screen, adjusting the brightness of the spot on the way to make up the picture. In the American system, 525 horizontal lines make up each frame and the scanning is repeated at a rate of 30 frames per second. In the British system, it's 625 lines and 25 complete frames per second . The connection for black-&-white is simple though -- Just a single signal carrying this luminance (brightness) information, plus a few extra pulses which are added to synchronize the scanning in the TV with that at the transmitter, but they need not concern us here.
Color TV adds a lot more complexity. A color picture is made up by scanning the tube with three separate beams, one each for the primary light colors of red, green, and blue. By adjusting the levels and proportions of these three colors any other color can be formed at a given point on the screen. Thus to form a color picture, we need three separate signals representing the three primary colors.
When you connect a monitor to your PC, or use the RGB (Red-Green-Blue) connections into your TV from, say, a DVD player, you are actually connecting these three signals individually. Keeping the three color signals completely separate provides excellent picture quality, but is not practical for color TV broadcasts.
For a start, broadcasting three separate signals would severely restrict the number of TV channels which could be fitted into the space available. When color TV was introduced an important consideration was also that there should be two-way compatiblity, i.e. that color TVs would correctly display a monochrome picture from existing black-&-white broadcasts and that existing black-&-white TVs should accept a color broadcast and correctly display the picture in the appropriate shades of gray. That would have been impossible by changing the system to transmit three completely separate video signals. (It would also have introduced many other technical problems, but I won't go into those!)
The overall luminance (brightness) of any given point on the picture is given by mixing red, green, and blue in the right proportions. In other words, there is an algebraic relationship such that if you know any three quantities, you can determine the fourth. That means that instead of transmitting separate signals for red, green, and blue, it's possible to transmit the overall luminance signal (generally symbolized as Y) plus just two of the individual color signals. The two colors chosen are red and blue.
Black-&-white TVs use only the luminance (Y) signal to display their monochrome picture. Color TVs take that luminance signal plus the two color signals and reconstruct the missing green color signal by simply subtracting red and blue from the overall luminance. In very simplified mathematical terms, if Y = R + G + B then G = Y - R - B. That also means that a color TV can show a black-&-white picture, because the b-&-w transmission has that luminance signal, just no extra color information.
Now, for various technical reasons, we don't actually transmit the red and blue signals in their original form. We convert them to what are called color difference signals. In other words, the red color-difference signal represents the amount by which the red component varies from the overall luminance. The blue color-difference signal represents the amount by which the blue component varies from the total, Y. That means that on a black-&-white picture, there are no color signals at all, since for any shade of gray the three RGB signals will always be in the same proportions.
If you have a piece of equipment which has Y/Pr/Pb component video connections, these are the signals you are connecting: Y is the luminance signal, representing the overall brightness. Pr is the red color-difference signal and Pb is the blue color-difference signal. (These connections are sometimes labeled Y/Cr/Cb instead.)
Again, connecting video as Y plus the two color-difference signals results in excellent picture quality, which is why these connections have become very common on equipment such as DVD players and HD TV sets.
Let's get back to TV broadcasting. What we have to do is find a way to send those two color-difference signals along with the luminance signal. We need not go into the details, but by using various electronic techniques it's possible to place a sub-carrier on the broadcast to carry extra signals. In other words, the main signal is the luminance, or Y, signal, just as on old black-&-white transmissions. The color signals are "piggybacked" onto that signal in such a way that they can be separated again at the receiver, and in fact the design is such that no extra radio spectrum is taken up.
This is where more national differences start to appear. The original American NTSC system piggybacks the two color signals onto the luminance signal for broadcast with little change. The resulting combined signal is then known variously as composite video, baseband video, or sometimes CVBS (which means Combined Video Blanking and Synchronization). This is what you have on the composite video output jack of your VCR or other equipment.
The British PAL color system uses a similar "piggyback" technique to carry the color signals, but the resulting composite video signal is not compatible with NTSC because the signals are altered in other ways first. In basic terms, PAL is a refinement of NTSC which adds a couple of extra signals to help cancel out any errors which can result in color shifts.
Because both NTSC and PAL were designed for broadcast use, the designs were, of necessity, something of a compromise between quality and keeping the overall broadcast signal within reasonable limits. Both do a very good job with properly adjusted equipment, but the NTSC or PAL encoding of the color does mean that a composite video connection does not give the same quality of picture as an RGB or Y/Pr/Pb component video connection. (Depending upon the overall quality of the equipment in use and of the source, the difference may not always be immediately apparent in all cases.)
What of Y/C (Luminance/Chrominance) connections, commonly referred to as S-video? It's really something of a halfway house, sending the luminance (brightness) and chroma (color) information separately, but the color portion is already fully encoded to the appropriate NTSC or PAL standard. In other words, if you took the chroma (C) portion and added it the luminance (Y) portion, you'd have composite video, and in fact it's possible to buy simple adapter leads which do just that.
In terms of quality, S-video lies between composite and component video. It eliminates some of the drawbacks of the combined Y/C of composite video, but because the color portion is already encoded it still has some of the limitations of NTSC or PAL signals.
Note that with component Y/Pr/Pb or RGB connections, there is essentially no difference between American and British standards other than the scanning rate (525 vs. 625 lines), so if the TV can cope with the different rates, the issue of NTSC vs. PAL doesn't arise. Composite and S-video connections, on the other hand, have the color signals encoded to the approriate NTSC of PAL standard, and thus are not compatible on a TV which is not designed to accept them.
Finally, we come to RF connections. At the TV transmitter, the composite video signal is modulated onto a very powerful carrier signal which is suitable for broadcasting. This is the signal you receive on your rooftop antenna and connect to the antenna/aerial socket on the back of your TV. The tuner in the TV has to select the appropriate channel from many, then decode this signal back to composite video before passing it on to the rest of the set.
When you connect a VCR or other source to your TV using just the coaxial antenna lead, the VCR has to simulate a TV broadcast by converting its signal to the same format. The TV then treats it just the same as any other off-air signal and decodes it back again. Even in the best of systems, each additional stage of conversion can add to degradation of the picture quality, and the modulators built in to most domestic VCRs, set-top boxes, etc. are not the greatest quality. Even on relatively low-range TVs the difference between viewing via the antenna socket and via a composite or other direct video connection is immediately obvious.
In terms of quality then, in descending order:
1. Component Y/Pr/Pb or RGB video
2. Y/C, otherwise known as S-video
3. Composite video
4. RF/aerial/antenna connection
Ideally, if you have enough component video inputs on your TV then use them for all your VCRs, DVD platers, Freeview boxes, etc. Otherwise, you may as well use the highest quality links for the sources offering the best potential quality pictures, such as your DVD player, then use the lesser inputs for sources which have a lower inherent quality.
You may have noticed that I've not yet mentioned the SCART connector. That's because it's not a specific format of video connection in itself, more a physical method of implementing the connections. SCART sockets have been fitted on British TVs since the early 1980s, and are now universal (although the number provided varies).
The SCART standard provides both composite and RGB video connections, although not all equipment supports both and not all SCART leads are wired for both. If you buy a "fully wired" SCART lead, then the TV will be able to use the direct RGB video when it's available, otherwise it will use composite.
I've not made any attempt to cover digital interfaces such as HDMI in this post, as that's getting into a whole different story.
Edited for a couple of minor typos.