Thanks for the advice, Helena!

(and to Andrea for clearing that up for me)
NY is the consulate for PA...I was in central PA and did it by post. I had no trouble at all---was worried about finances but it wasn't an issue. Personally if you can do it in person without a huge hassle I would only because the worrying and stress of waiting for an answer is the hardest part. When it is done in person you have one stressful day and then it is over! When I was married I went in person for my FLR and it was well worth the extra money in point of view.
As far as people advising to get married in the states---that is really a personal decision. I know you save the fee and hassle of having to do visas but you have to weigh that against paying for airfare for your fiance to fly the states and back again.
That's how I see things--if you know PA geography you'll know that Scranton (my hometown) is a reasonable daytrip from NY, so that's certainly something we could pull off. In fact, I went there to get my student visa--so quick, painless and the same day! I do know how much it depends on the officer, though--all they asked was to see my acceptance letter and bam! I was done. Not even bank statements or even asked anything about finances. The poor girl behind me, who I'd been making pleasant conversation with while we were waiting, was going to be an exchange student at Oxford and got ridiculously grilled because she hadn't gotten her Stafford Loans yet (but then, neither had I!). I know it sounds terrible, but I sometimes wonder if what made the difference is that I had all my things organized in a binder and was well dressed, and she looked like, well . . .
a student.
Anthony and I have talked about where it would happen before, and I don't remember if I mentioned it on this thread or the one on LJ, but since I'm the only child of the family, my parents have mentioned covering expenses if we do it at home. Bureaucracy aside, that's what I'd prefer myself, as I have a large family and weddings function as family reunions for us (another reason why my parents have said they'd help with costs, they want to see relatives they only get to see every few years too!). Anthony, of course, is more laid back about the whole thing and says he'd be glad to, just so long as I'm his wife when it's over.

We're thinking of having something smaller, maybe a blessing of our vows or something back home for his family and our UK friends who couldn't make it.
I know 2008 (maybe 2007, if he gets lucky with a well-paying job right away) is a while off yet, but I feel like if I wait too long to get the answers to these questions, we might be screwed! Both his and my immediate family know we're planning this, and we have some engagement rings picked out (he's going to pick "the one", though, so I'll be surprised

). Unfortunately, we can't get the ring (and thus, set a date) until he's employed, and we want to have a countdown to when the distance will be over for good! (He's just gone back home to hunt for jobs last week, so we're in an LDR after a whole year together. It's absolute agony. :\\\'()
Okay, that was a novel. Thanks again for your help!
