This thread is a bit run out, but I thought I'd reply as I just got back from setting up our registry at John Lewis (the free food was a perk!).
I was definitely of the no-registry school. I like to get gifts that people choose for you because they put thought and heart into the choosing. But, like so many people said, it was the guests who clamoured for us to register.
The other deciding factor was the massive expense of shipping things from the US (where the wedding is) to the UK (where we'll live) And my inability to explain to some relatives that they could not buy us any American electonics (no really they won't work, really
). John Lewis is holding everything for three weeks after the wedding, then they'll deliver it to our flat. The convenience is worth bending my principles.
I have put my foot down against a shower though. I definitely don't need two sets of gifts. My mother has instead arranged a 'shower of wisdom'. She and her closest friends are going to come over for tea and shower me with stories of married life, useful recipes and gardening tips, and anything else that comes to mind. At first I was unsure, but now I'm looking forward to it. Getting married is such a life changing event, and I will appreciate their love and support far more than anything I could scan at John Lewis.
...though a kitchenaid mixer would be nice too...