Wow, thanks again folks. Who knew this would be a 2 pager thread!
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/c2959/c295920285507a4049ea1b8940d8901e3bf18c24" alt="Cheesy :D"
Anne you reminded me of my mother... we have a cookbook that everyone in our family has a copy of. It's out of print now, but one of the best cookbooks ever. That said, there are some really good and
really bad recipes in it. My mother, for as long as I can recall, has written in pencil 'good', 'excellent', and most importantly 'NO!' next to ones she's tried. When I ordered my copy off a used book site, I made her go through it and do the same!
I think it's going to have to be plastic sleeves for me. I think I have way too many recipes for one of the pre-made recipe binders like Dodo. I also have a spiral bound notebook from Paperchase with sections in a different colors. I've been hand writing some of my TOP recipes in it to try to create a bit of an heirloom book. As Sammy gets older, we'll add photos and stuff to it as well.
Now, off to buy some plastic sleeves!