Hello! I love Pie. I mean, I really LOVE pie! This thread is making me drool onto my keyboard.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/82faf/82faf468054bab277e9333be68685caf73713f94" alt="Grin ;D"
I'm still in France, the land of the tart, and let me tell you, tart is not pie. It is good, but not pie.
I voted for make my own with butter. I always use my hands to cut the butter into the flour, same as with biscuits. The first time I tried to make pie with my husband (who is French and a chef) I went into spasms because he was doing it all wrong. "What are you doing? Stop, stop, stop! Please step away from the dough, you're working it too much. It has to just barely stay together." Needless to say, he thought I was over-reacting a wee bit.
But for me, pie crust is serious business, especially when I'm trying to make comfort food, which tastes like home. If I'm making a tart or quiche, I just go to the store and buy "pate brisee" which is the French version of pie crust (and what poor honey was trying to do). Otherwise, it is straight out of the
Betty Crocker Picture Cookbook, just like I learned when I was little.
Oh, and I almost forgot. My first sentence when I was a baby? "More Pie"!
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/82faf/82faf468054bab277e9333be68685caf73713f94" alt="Grin ;D"