I know you've already made your pie, but just for future reference, try lining the pan with parchment paper! Butter and shortening are totally fab, don't get me wrong, but I sometimes still have problems with the crust sticking when I do that. Parchment paper won't burn in the oven, it makes cleaning up a bit easier, and NOTHING sticks to it! I use it for pies, cakes, cookies, brownies..pretty much everything! If you leave a bit sticking over the sides of the pan if you're making a cake or brownies, all you have to do is pull the paper slowly and the cake or whatever lifts right out of the pan without crumbling or breaking (cakes falling apart whilst trying to get them out of the pan was the bane of my existence for the looooooooongest time). Just a suggestion!
And what's with all the negative 'bakingly challenged' talk? Anyone can whip up far out baked goods, it just takes a wee bit of practise! I've been baking since before I could talk and I still mess up loads, haha!
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/c2959/c295920285507a4049ea1b8940d8901e3bf18c24" alt="Cheesy :D"
LOL at the Easy Bake! ^_^