Once you select 2555, you select 2555 for each subsequent year until you revoke your right to claim 2555. After you revoke the 2555, you can't file a 2555 for five years. So only stop filing the 2555 if the savings is substantial.
Each year, you can file any one of three ways:
* 2555 alone
* 1116 alone
* or, if your income is high enough 2555 and then 1116 for the income in excess of the 2555.
So it's actually three different methods, not two.