Well, this year on the way to the inlaws I asked Mr A which he thought I'd get: a handbag or a scarf. Basically, every year since practically forever this is what I've gotten. Sometimes I get them for my birthday as well. They are never anything I'd carry (or if a scarf, nothing I'd ever wear).
So we were opening our gifts and I got a handbag. We were about to move on when my mother-in-law told me to look inside because there was a matching scarf. She must have seen it and thought of me. Perfect. Both a scarf AND a handbag (although it seemed to be one of those free gift things for ordering stuff and smelled heavily of dye so I doubt she saw it anywhere before it ended up with a shipment of other stuff from a catalogue). It was all Mr A and I could do not to burst out laughing and couldn't look at each other for over ten minutes.
MiL says (as she has in the past) that I am so hard to buy for. Almost everyone else I know says that I am one of the easiest people to buy gifts for. I don't mean to sound ungrateful, but their family's gifts always seem to reflect what they judge is the economic makeup of our marriage. I literally get stuff from charity shops or the stuff that looks like they came as a bonus gift to catalogue orders. They always splash out for my husband. Yes, he is their child and I don't expect parity or anything. It's just it's hard to say that it's the thought that counts when there wasn't much thought in any gift they've ever given me. Well, that's not true. My FiL usually hits it about spot on when he goes shopping, but he's rarely well enough to do it on his own.