Hiya
Jim - German cars, all of them enjoy their biggest markets.. in North America. When the car is in warranty, they're pretty much like any other car and repairs are covered. When out of warranty, the USA has plenty of specialist's capable of repairing them with ease and at decent prices. The predominantly 99% American 2 other car forums I goto attest that repairs are just as easy to do as say a domestic car brand models.
However, I do understand that the german brands are more slightly more 'status' orientated than say here in the UK and as such, tend to attract more affluent buyers - and as such, general pricing for maintenance is correspondingly higher - just the way of the world really! if you can get away with charging more, then you do exactly that!
The 'trend' of overall car league tables do show German brands often lower down than you'd think, Mercedes for a good while have been panned in the build quality stakes compared from their reputation a few years prior of solid bomb proof fit and build, however, when compared with other cars overall, there's no doubt, the German brands outshine many of the others in more areas.
there is always an air of personal preference when it comes to comparing brands/products and i'm as guilty as anyone else when it comes to supporting ones I've liked and not liked.
My choice is also based on seeing first hand in various crashes (all NOT my fault!) how a BMW ends up and how a Peugeot 406, Vauxhall Corsa and a Ford Mondeo end up at low/medium speed impacts.
I know in which car I'd rather be.
Balmerhon - Yep, you're better half will probably be able to pickup on if the Subaru Outback model you're looking at has that type of engine. I'm not trying to dissuade you - well ok, yes I am a bit!! - but I think you'd find a better performing vehicle for similar money - certainly in the fuel economy stakes, if its got a convential engine style/layout.
As per usual, reading up on suitable material to help decide what car you can and should go for (even if it is an Outback!) is best place to start, and then making up a shortlist should follow!
Good luck !
cheers! DtM! West London & Slough UK!