My personal favorite was Good Food. I didn't subscribe but bought it religiously and I miss it terribly. I found that for me, it had the most accessible recipes, best info on buying local/organic, and most interesting tips and articles. One of the others, I can't recall which, is also part of the BBC publications I think. I believe it's Olive... anyway, that one, IIRC, is just more high end, more restaurant review, etc. Much as I enjoyed that, the restuarant reviews just ended up annoying me as between budget and location, I rarely got to any of them!!
I wish I could do a foodie mag exchange! Anyone there want to swap for Bon Appetit, Cooking LIght, or some other?!