A friend recommended The Historian by Elizabeth Kostova. OMG... horrible. Dh and I both have MAs in History and it just made us want to slam our heads in doors repeatedly. The concept was awful and the storytelling I just found to be horrible. I may have already said this one, but it so deserves to be panned again.
This makes me so happy. I could not stand the book, and I was the only person I know who didn't absolutely love it. I was so excited, because all the sources I trusted were on and on about this amazing new novel and author.
I hated it. Even if I could set the history aside (which I struggled with; I can't stand poetic license with known histories), the story was put together clumsily. What most annoyed me, though, was that Kostova could write some really moving passages and describe places fantastically. When a good writer doesn't carry his or her potential all the way, it makes a weak book even worse. From what I understand, she spent something like ten years writing it, but I guess after that, she was ready to get it to a publisher and out the door, so there doesn't seem to have been much time spent editing.