It's a much more complicated story than we thought at first, and I'm going to tell the long version because it's the best
I met my fiance in 2005, when he was working at the Massachusetts summer camp that I'd gone to for the last few years, except that summer I'd decided not to go back. I visited the camp for a weekend, and went out for ice cream with some of my friends. Since he was friends with them also, he came too. He thought I was cute from the first time he saw me, but he thought I was dating the boy who was actually just my best friend, so he never said anything. Even then though, one of our mutual friends hinted that he thought we'd be good together
In 2006, I went back to the camp but he didn't. But in 2007 we were both working there. We were easy friends from the first day, and a few days in we were flirting... but I thought he was gay, haha, because I was NOT used to guys actually being interested in me.
During the first week, we had our day off together on the 4th of July. I had a car so we decided to go off camp to do something. On the way out, I got up the courage to ask if all that flirting actually meant he liked me, and he said yes, but it was kind of awkward and we didn't know what to say beyond that. Then we kind of... pretended that hadn't happened. We went to dinner and Walmart (heh, it was the only place to hang out, we were in the middle of nowhere), and then we went to a grocery store and literally sat down in the middle of the candy aisle, talking about which candies we liked and disliked. Then we decided to drive into CT to find some fireworks, because they're not allowed in MA. We watched them with a beautiful song, "Dark Blue" by Jack's Mannequin, blasting on my stereo. When they ended, we drove back to camp. But by the time we got back it was pouring, and we didn't want to get out of the car, so we stayed in the car, talking and laughing with the lights off. Eventually we moved to the backseat, and then he kissed me once and we went back to the camp. It was honestly one of the most perfect days of my entire life. But the next day I asked him what was up between us, and he was kind of weird about it and said we should hold off from doing anything about it.
A few days later, I found out he'd been sort of hooking up with another girl at the camp. I was devastated because I really liked him, and I really thought he liked me. I told her what had happened, and we both refused to talk to him (although he tried!). But eventually he made me sit down so he could tell me the real story: he wasn't even sure what he had with that other girl, but he had been trying to end it with her before he would go out with me, because he hated the idea of cheating and he wanted to make sure he wasn't doing that. He really wanted to
date me, whereas he'd just been hooking up with the other girl. I was still a little mad, but on my next day off I was bringing back presents for all my friends, and I remembered how much he'd liked the Jack's Mannequin CD, so I made a copy for him and gave it to him the next day. The rest of the week, I heard "Dark Blue" playing from his cabin nearly every time I walked by, and I was amused that he'd be listening to the same song on repeat, thinking he must REALLY like that song.
A few days later, I admitted to our mutual friend (the same one who originally said we'd be good together) that I still liked him. Then THEY had a day off together, and our friend told my boy what I'd said. The second they got back, my boy asked me if I wanted to watch a movie that night, after our kids were in bed. I said okay, and that night we put on a movie (it was Elf
) and sat down to watch it. Halfway through, he said "So, our friend told me something... but I'm not sure if it's true..." And I said "You mean that I still like you? Yeah, I said that." And we sat there watching the movie for a few minutes, then he kissed me. A while later that same night (after lots of kissing!), I asked "So is this official now?" And he said yes.
And now here we are, a year and a half later, engaged
Postscript: He later (much later) admitted that he wasn't just listening to "Dark Blue" all the time... he waited for me to walk by his cabin, and when he saw me he would change it to that song, wanting to let me know that he was thinking of me.