Since it was always just DH and I, I'd get a frozen turkey crown from M&S. I would make gravy using a nice fresh chicken broth that I'd splurge on a bit (rather than the stuff in the can or cubes). I never had a pie pan when I was there, so I didn't make pies, but apple pie is super easy to make. I'm not a huge fan of pumpkin pie, so I'd make some other form of pumpkin dessert, like cake, cookies, or bread!