The Crimson White, UA’s student newspaper, reported that Alireza Doroudi, a mechanical engineering student, was detained by ICE at 5 a.m. on March 25 in his home. The newspaper reported that Doroudi entered the country in January 2023, and was notified a few months later that his F-1 student visa was revoked. Doroudi contacted UA’s International Student and Scholar Services, who told him the notification “was not unusual or problematic and that he could remain in the U.S. as long as he maintained his student status.” Someone with the name Alireza Doroudi is listed as “in ICE custody,” according to the agency’s website. The detention facility isn’t listed.
[[SNIP]]
[COMMENT - If someone at UA's ISSS told him that he could stay in-country with an invalid F1, he was badly misinformed. If he was in the process of appealing the revoking of the visa, that's possibly different, but there is no mention of that being the case. If your visa is revoked, you have 15 days to scram out of here. Something does not add up here. If he was an overstayer in mid-2023, they should have deported him by early 2024 at the latest. He's Iranian, not the favorite nationality of the week, so I doubt he'd be skating through unknown. There's some missing pieces to this story.]
I could be mistaken in what I wrote, above. It's down to the actual wording of the situation and what the student was told. There are two factors - the Student Visa (F1) and "status" at play. The visa is what gets you into the country. Normally as long as one is fulfilling the terms of the visa application - making appropriate progress in one's academic program or training - one remains "in status" and is allowed to remain in the country even after one's visa expires. So if the student in question's visa had only expired, he should have been fine and the advice he was given was accurate at that time.
If one falls "out of status", depending on the reason (graduation, illness, poor performance, etc.) the amount of time one has available to leave the country or transfer to another program (if appropriate) varies depending on the reason. SEE here for a clearer explanation -
https://www.visaverge.com/immigration/staying-legally-in-usa-expired-visa-but-valid-immigration-status/Normally only the University/training program adjusts "status" in the SEVIS system, the tracking system for foreign students.There have been reports online that someone other than university personnel has manually changed some students' status. Since, according to those reports, the institutions were supposedly not involved, they would have no way to know that any sort of ICE action was going to be instituted against the students.
I have no way to know if any of the info about some mysteriously diddling with SEVIS entries is correct. If it is, let's just say I would not be surprised. Disgusted - if the schools were not notified - but not surprised to hear someone on "the other end" of the system had manually changed the status. There apparently was a Supreme Court case late last year that gave HHS (and so ICE) great leeway in cancelling student visas, without judicial oversight. SEE
https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/nri/us-canada-news/us-supreme-court-upholds-discretionary-revocation-of-visa-applications/articleshow/116237893.cmsAs far as I can tell, some of the ICE actions were "legal" in that the students in question had overstayed - some by quite a long time. This still should just get them put on a flight to their own country, not sent to a gulag for months-to-years. That's just wrong in every sense of the meaning of "wrong."
Here is the latest I find, generically, about students being "disappeared" -
https://www.cnn.com/2025/03/31/us/what-we-know-college-activists-immigration-hnk/index.html